Registration-free COM components try-out (continued)

As described in the previous post, I am trying out Side By Side (reg free) COM, trying to solve versioning and deployment issues we have with our software. In the previous post, I looked at VB6 and COM, this post is about my adventures with .NET and COM. The conclusion is: don't use the walkthrough as is, you won't be able to get a successful regfree installation.

.NET and COM

Step 1 Read the walkthrough.

Step 2 Create the COM enabled .NET dll and the VB6 client app
Use Guid.NewGuid().ToString() to create GUIDs for the .NET assembly, class and interface if guidgen is not working for some reason. I created a new windows forms exe which copies a new Guid to the clipboard and exits. Start the vb6 exe to see if it works.

Step 3 unregister the .NET dll
with c:\windows\Microsoft.NET\Framework\v2.0.50727\regasm /u SideBySide.dll. Start the vb6 exe and see that it doesn't work any more.

Step 4 Create the manifest files for the dll and the client exe.
The example manifest in the walkthrough contains errors. FAIL. For example: //assemblyIdentity/@name=" SideBySide" should be "SideBySide", without the space. And //clrClass/@progid="SideBySide.SideBySide" should be "SideBySide.SideBySideClass".

Step 5 Do voodoo magic to embed the manifest into the dll
- Create a resource definition file which references the SideBySide.manifest file
- Create a build.cmd file which creates the resource file and compiles it into SideBySide.dll
Run build.cmd in a VS command prompt (%comspec% /k ""C:\Program Files\Microsoft Visual Studio 9.0\VC\vcvarsall.bat"" x86)

Step 6 Start client.exe
Now it should work... gaaah! Automation error!

Step 7 Take hours to troubleshoot
- The error is 80070002, which is supposed to mean "file not found". There are however no entries in the windows event log, and no entries in fuslogvw by which i could get a diagnosis of the problem.
- Googling on the error is not helpful.
- The assembly should have an embedded manifest. Open the file in VS, check: obviously has the right manifest file.
- Manifest files seem to be correct. But because the example in the walkthrough had errors, i feel uncertain about it.
- Because the dll has no version information if you view the properties in Windows Explore, i though that might have to do with the problem. I tried to embed the manifest using Visual Studio. After that, it works, but that is because "register for COM interop" was still checked. Regasm-ing /u and it won't work any more. The file still has no file version properties - but i'm not sure if that is a problem.
- Tried adding the interface to the manifest file also, still fails.
- Tried to build everything from scratch: same automation error occurs.
- I was thinking: we had issues with our own software that appeared after building VB6 exe's against .NET COM dll's and then rebuilding the COM dll's. That could be a problem, so i will test it: build the .NET dll with embedded manifest file and after that rebuild the vb6 exe. Still fails.
- Ok starting from scratch again.
- Tried all variations of the manifest files i could think of: Still fails with the automation error

Step 8 Give up for now.
I have no ideas left. Do some hopeless i-give-up-but-i-dont-want-to-admit-it-browsing and hey, a tool to generate the manifest files instead of having to make them yourself. The tool is called genman32, and is made by Junfeng Zhang, who has some articles about SxS / RegFree com.

Step 9 Having new hope, try again with the genman32 tool
The tool generates a manifest using reflection and is able to embed it in the dll. The generated manifest is unfortunately not correct.. But i could correct the errors and then use the tool to embed the corrected manifest.
- Create manifest with "genman32 <dll>"
- Correct the manifest (<dll>.manifest): Remove /assembly/assemblyIdentity/@processorArchitecture and add /assembly/assemblyIdentity/@type='win32'.
- Embed the manifest in the dll with "genman32 <dllname> /add /manifest:<manifestname>

Step 10 Start the Vb6 exe
Ha! Now it works!! Double check by regasm-ing /u the assembly... still works!! The only difference with my "manual" tries is that the dll now has version information embedded as well. It seems that having this version information is not optional. The manual process described in the walkthrough removes this information, while the genman32 tool preserves it (which is compiled into the dll by Visual Studio automatically).

Conclusion

The document "Registration-Free Activation of .NET-Based Components: A Walkthrough" is not correct and it cost me time and frustration. And i am probably not the only person with this experience. I will provide this story as feedback on the article and i hope the article will be corrected.

But apart from that, the good news is: I do have a way of using .NET COM components in VB6 regfree. I should try this with .NET OCX files too...

Registration-Free COM components try-out

We have both .NET components and VB6 legacy apps. We created a communication layer between the two, both ways, using COM interop.
Unfortunately, this breaks the xcopy install for our .NET software. And introduces unexpected and nasty versioning issues.

Enter reg-free com. This might solve some of these issues. Updating is reduced to copying a new version of the dll, and it even makes possible that different versions of one COM server exist side-by-side (which happened to be the reason behind this technology in the first place).

I record my adventures using registration free COM on this blog for future reference.

VB6 and COM

Step 1 Read the walkthrough.

Step 2 Create the COM and client applications

Step 3 regsvr32 /u sidebyside.dll
And notice that the client exe will now fail.

Step 3 Create manifest files
which hold the information that makes XP find the COM server without the registry.

To know by which GUIDs the component is known, the OLE/COM object viewer is a very nice tool. It can be downloaded from the Microsoft site. The download does not include an essential dll, iviewers.dll, (obviously this has not been tested thoroughly), which can be downloaded from this location. After install, your system has not been polluted with shorcuts to any exe whatsoever, and the program can be found at this intuitive location: "%ProgramFiles%\Resource Kit"

I created a sendto command to drop the dll's onto the exe, which will then show you the information you need.

The "walkthrough" does not walk me through which GUID maps to what attribute in the xml file, but my guessing was right:
/assembly/file/comClass/@clsid maps on the uuid on "coclass SideBySideClass"
/assembly/file/typeLib/@tlbid maps on the uuid on "library SideBySide" (topmost uuid)
/assembly/comInterfaceExternalProxyStub/@iid maps on uuid on "interface _SideBySideClass : IDispatch"
/assembly/comInterfaceExternalProxyStub/@tlbid is the same as /assembly/file/typeLib/@tlbid

Step 4 Start the client exe and celebrate that it works for VB6 exe to COM dll.

Tomorrow: .NET and COM.